Rookie of the Year

Parallel AIs

This column is a reprint from Unwinnable Monthly #130. If you like what you see, grab the magazine for less than ten dollars, or subscribe and get all future magazines for half price.


A tongue-in-cheek but also painfully earnest look at pop culture and anything else that deserves to be ridiculed while at the same time regarded with the utmost respect. It is written by Matt Marrone and emailed to Stu Horvath, who adds any typos or factual errors that might appear within.


My good friends at Reddit point out that the plot of Westworld season three shares parallels with Jonathan Nolan’s previous television series, Person of Interest. So when Westworld season three ended, I decided to start binging Person of Interest on Netflix.

Now that I’ve reached Person of Interest season three, I can share what is likely an unpopular opinion: It’s a much better show than Westworld.

To be clear, Person of Interest is essentially a police procedural with some bells and whistles. Mostly, it’s just an easy show to consume while I ride my stationary bike at night. I don’t feel a need to be too critical of its missteps and its often very convenient and hard to swallow hacking tricks, not to mention Jim Caviezel’s ability to be shot again and again or get into multiple car wrecks and always walk away unscathed. Furthermore, in no way does it touch the brilliance of Westworld season one, which is one of the all-time great seasons of television.

But let’s face it: Westworld season three was a brutal disappointment, following Westworld season two, which now is but a mild disappointment in comparison.

So all of a sudden it becomes particularly fair game to compare a prestige cable TV epic to a relatively run-of-the-mill network drama — especially with the parallels I mention above.

In Westworld season three, the all-knowing computer is called Rehoboam. In Person of Interest, it’s called several things, mainly The Machine, but my favorite might be Northern Lights, the name of the secret government project that oversees it.

But here’s the difference: though the characters could be far more nuanced, to say the least, the ones in Person of Interest are more likable, easier to root for, and generally just better realized, than what we get from the characters in Westworld season three. Their motives are clearer and make more sense, and while you’re not asked to do the same amount of work as in Westworld season three, that just means you don’t have the frustration of discovering it was a waste of time.

The writing, too, is better. Yes, I just typed that sentence. If I’d typed that sentence after Westworld season one, I’d invite you to slap me across the mouth. Now, though, it’s just truth. Sure, Person of Interest loses points for not trying as hard as Westworld season three does to deliver a transcendent message. But it makes up those points – and then some – for not failing so miserably at it.

All that being said, Rookie of the Year columns aren’t supposed to be about trashing other people’s work. If you liked Westworld season three, I’m happy for you. I feel sorry for you, but . . . kidding! I am genuinely glad you liked it.

So instead, I’m going to point out three of my favorite things about Person of Interest.

  • Because you don’t know at the outset of each episode whether the person they’re tracking is the victim or perpetrator, you can be reasonably sure they’ll keep you guessing. And mostly they’re actually pretty good at it.
  • It has heart. The main characters are silly in their own ways (Michael Emerson is impossibly clever, and even more impossibly wealthy, and Caviezel, as I said, is impossibly indestructible) and you can also tear apart the other characters in various ways, but mostly they’re just really enjoyable because they’re so damn likable. You root for the good guys and you even root for the bad guys because they’re fun too and even have a moral code of their own that’s entertaining to trace. And tons of smart, strong women are in the mix, also.
  • The Machine is an AI with a soul. While Rehoboam turns its creator into a puppet and people into puppets, too, Northern Lights – also designed to do nefarious things to keep humans in line – appears to care about them. Beyond the altruism of preventing “irrelevant” deaths, it wants to protect its creator, even as that creator tries to train it not to. It’s doing some funky stuff right now that I don’t understand – and could shift my opinion of it a bit – but ultimately, I dig it. Both Rehoboam and The Machine eliminate uncertainty in the name of protecting humanity from its destruction, but only one of them seems to have any empathy.

Anyway, as I said, I’m not here to trash art. If I were, I would write 2,000 words on Westworld season three. Which, again, sucked. But maybe that’s why I’m liking Person of Interest so much: because it’s allowing me to still dislike Westworld season three, but to focus more on liking a “lesser” show that does similar things a whole lot better. Which is a much more rewarding thing to do.


Matt Marrone is a senior MLB editor at He has been Unwinnable’s reigning Rookie of the Year since 2011. You can follow him on Twitter @thebigm.

Ad Free, Rookie of the Year, TV, Unwinnable Monthly